Atticus told Scout that “the Ewell’s had been a disgrace to Maycomb for generations...They were people, but they lived like animals” (40). Readers find out that the Ewells live on the corner of the town garbage dump, often living without food, clean clothing, or money. This is quite similar to the families viewed in “A Hidden America: Children of the Mountains.”
Mayella Ewell accuses an innocent man, of a horrible crime. This is a harsh, mean action, which would lead a reader to thinking that she is a terrible person. But, even though Mayella lies on the witness stand, she still can be seen as a sympathetic character. Perhaps one of the most shocking things about Mayella is that she is different from the rest of her family. She “[looks] as if she [tries] to keep clean” and has a flower garden that is “cared for as tenderly as if [it] belonged to Maudie Atkinson” in their otherwise disgusting yard (179) (171). This shows her kindness and thoughtfulness.
Knowing this, why should readers sympathize (as Atticus does) with Mayella Ewell?
Why do you think she makes the decisions she makes in relation to going along with the trial?
What strategies does the author use to make sure readers will feel some sympathy toward her? Do you?